Tony`s Pizzalicious in Cayce

Love the pizza great small restaurant That I think you'll love to give it a try.

So delicious 😋 you have to try the pizza 🍕

Food was above average for similar establishments. Service was slow because they appeared to be under staffed. Dining area was clean. Would recommend this restaurant for a quiet dining area with a decent menu.

Dont get the gyro salad. Absolutely disgusting. The gyro meat was dry an old. The tzatziki sauce smelled an tasted like fish. The best thing about this meal was the service. Even the waitress said it was nasty after i stopped eating it.

Excellent authentic Italian eatery very ducked off homey vibe great staff.great for the whole family

Large portions, fair prices,delicious food.

Food was great and the service was excellent. The bathroom could use some attention.

the pasta is so good and it is enough to eat the next day. the girl at the drive thru was nice and gave me an extra drink when I had to wait for my food to be ready. five stars

I visit this spot a lot since I work close by. I have to say their customer service is always good and they keep the place clean at all times. Pricing is reasonable and they serve generous portions.

Food was amazing! Baked ziti w/bacon was awesome, kids devoured the spaghetti and meat sauce, pasta with marinara was good also. Chain places are safe and comfortable but this place crushes them!!

Wife and I stopped in for lunch this past Sat 02-23 and it was our first trip. In years past I often had lunch at the Tony's on Knott Abbott when it was owned by this same family and it was always consistently good. My wife had the Lasagna and I had the Spaghetti, salad & bread. Both the spaghetti and salad were very good and tasted very much as I remember at their original location and the lasagna was good as well. Granted there are some things that will improve over time as it takes time to create a master piece. Give these folks a try as I know we will return again.

Staff went above and beyond in the services rendered!!....pizzas are delicious😀

Great pizza and delicious gyro salad. Heather is a fantastic server!!

Place is dated but the pizza is good. Staff is nice. Get the Dimi's deluxe cooked extra crispy...you won't be disappointed

I have the baked ziti I will be going back that was very delicious in the price wasn't bad either

Food was on the pricey side and the meals were just not that great. We ordered subs, which were to come with Cole slaw and fries. When we received the meal, there was no slaw. We asked about it and the waitress said that they have never had it and did not understand why it was on the menu. This should have been stated before ordering, not after we receive the meal. Not deduction in price for not having the slaw.

Nothing like Demi's pizza

They service was wonderful and the pizza was delicious as well as the cheese bread. Only downside they do not serve alcohol and a glass of wine would have been nice with my pizza. Other than that it was wonderful.

Don't Order the Lasagna Worst I've ever Eaten in my LIFE .Garlic bread was Burned .Lettuce Salad .Was not worth the 10.00 I payed NEVER GOING BACK EVER....

Great FOOD...GREAT SERVICE!

The food is AMAZING and the staff is beyond friendly. The owner is a great guy that really cares about his business, customers and employees.

Ordered a pepperoni pizza, got home and found out it was a plain pizza, ate it anyway and it was the nastiest pizza I ever tasted. Won't go thereagain

Staff are nice and awesome. Food is awesome with grand portions. Quality 10/10 place for Italian food,

Stopped in for lunch. Had a small pizza. It came pretty quick. It was good. Sauce was heavy on the oregano and could have used more garlic for my taste. Service was good. The booths could use recovering. Well worth another visit.

Went here for a pizza. Have been told it's a great place to eat by many locals. I was met at the counter by an employee as soon as I entered. Menu was easy to read and I could find my selection quickly. Many different menu items that sounded wonderful to eat. Got my pizza quick enough and it looked great. As I ate the pizza I found it to be very tasty, although I prefer thicker crust it was good.

Great prices, good food with large portions and good, friendly service.

DELICIOUS!! Authentic, hot, perfection! Coming from NY I have been searching for a great pizza, pasta and sub spot this place tastes even better! Our server Robin is the sweetest we will come back for her too! Try the Taztziki in the Greek Delight appetizer with toasted Pita ,it's clearly made by a Greek! Yummm

Good food and great customer service.

Delicious thin crust pizza! Generous toppings! Super Nice service! We just tried it for the first time after years of living in the area. We will be back! Loved it!!

Too many times we try and call only to be told that they are closed or no longer taking orders well within their posted hours. This isn't exclusively related to holiday times since this has happened for over a year now at random times. This last time which inspired this review was a holiday period. Because of our past experience of unreliability, we called ahead in the afternoon to check the hours and were told they would be open. Called an hour later, and they changed their minds and decided to close. For the sake of customers and employees, please commit to and post reliable hours (including holiday closures).

We visited Tony's Pizzalicious, on tonight and everything was phenomenal. We were greeted upon entering the door, and we seated ourselves. We had Deedle as a waitress, her personality was bubbly and she was very attentive to our needs although she was the only waiteress on duty, she WORKED the room! We ordered cheese sticks, a large half pepperoni, half black olives pizza and a kids chicken tender meal for my son. Everything came out piping hot and served to us in a timely manner. We will definitely be frequent customer's.

Great food, fair prices. Awesome staff, very friendly. They make you feel welcome and comfortable. They have been at the same location as far as I can remember. Large portions of food. Can't go wrong if your eating in or take out. Highly recommend!!!

The place was rather slow this day but we still waited a pretty good amount of time for everything. They had nothing we asked for, it was either we needed to wait until it got cooked or they no longer serve that even though it's on the menu. And the price is definitely not worth the food you get.

We did not like the food. The waitress during covid was not wearing her mask properly, touched the opened straws, spoons, forks and everything else with her hands, on the parts you eat or drink off of. We then just asked for plastic silverware. We paid 40 dollars for 3 meals and none of us liked them. We had a calzone, a meatball sub and some fettuccine and all were gross. We left feeling hungry and discusted.

Super service with a smile by Ann(?),she greeted me,seated me,took my order and kept my glass full.The small Dimi's Deluxe Pizza was the perfect size,with enough left over for breakfast the following morning.....

Coming from a Yankee from NY...... BEST PIZZA IN TOWN!! Excellent service!! Will be back many times

This place is great for a quick Italian fix that isn't mainstream. Their calzones are huge and filled with a delicious ricotta cheese sauce. I also love their chicken Alfredo pizza. The only disappointing thing I've had are their 'Jumbo' wings, which were more like the smallest I've ever seen. Their prices are reasonable.

Great pizza and wings. Kirsten did a super job. Back again next week 🍕🍕🍕

It's rare to find GOOD pizza in the south, but Tony's has owners from up north and their food reflects that. I have always been greeted warmly and more than satisfied with their food. Family friendly and priced reasonably, you won't be disappointed in Tony's.

Wonderful service, slightly doughy pizza. It wasn't bad, I like of like doughy crust, but it was not what I was expecting. I would definitely recommend the place though. 😊

My college daughters love Pizza and we have literally eaten pizza everyday for a week. One of those days was at Tony's and it was by far the best pizzeria in Columbia! It's the best of NY and Chicago mix. Thin crust in middle with thick crunchy edge crust and perfect size toppings with lots of cheese!

Pizza is insanely good

Reasonably friendly but behind on prep time with no updates

I've been eating here since I was a little girl! It's where I picked to eat after high school graduation. It's also where my husband and I picked up spaghetti at the drive thru window just an hour after we'd eloped. That was 39 yrs ago. We've even brought grandchildren there to eat. 🍝😀We'll be back to eat soon

Awesome place. Great oiza and friendly service

Please is dirty in much need of repair ( seats ripped, tables are gross), had spaghetti and meatballs way to much sauce on it and meatballs were soggy and flavorless, my grandson had grilled cheese and it was burnt with not enough cheese for bread being used. I can say the waitress was very nice and great at her job but the cook came out to dinning room and was making very unfavorable comments about someone using inappropriate language loud enough for myself and grandchildren could hear

AMAZING! I moved to SC over a year ago from up north and I had yet to find an Italian place with truly authentic Italian cuisine, until I came here - this place IS IT! They have the BEST marina sauce outside of New York, and the owner and staff are wonderful! Make Tony's your regular spot!

Delicious food and healthy portions for the price

Good food, great service.